The Argumentative Indian: the curious case of a nation that loves to talk but not act!
Thursday, March 31st, 2011That’s one of my favorite Jack Welch quotes. The former CEO of General Electric succinctly put across one of the most elemental truths of life. How often we find ourselves stuck in a cobweb of strategizing and relenting little on the importance of acting on it. Both strategy and execution are interdependent, but while the former requires intellect and an ability to think, the latter is more about sustained leadership commitment, processes, firmness and discipline.
While the West has realized the importance of execution, we Indians have always relegated action to the background, favoring strategy instead. At the organizational level, our ability to act promptly is stymied by lack of focus, disinterest in following processes and inability to put across a timely framework for measurable development.
As a people, we are opinionated and have a take on every hot button topic. We perennially discuss and debate issues that ail the nation. But we fail to look at the reasons that are impeding growth. Consequently, even as we make noise, we do not take any action or provide solutions. Maybe Amartya Sen had the same thoughts when he titled his book The Argumentative Indian.
If only we could be like the Japanese. Look at the sheer resilience they displayed last month. While the whole world was discussing and giving macro views on Japan’s future in the wake of the near apocalyptic earthquake and tsunami, the resolute Japanese went about demonstrating what action can achieve. In an amazing display of stubborn determination, they rebuilt the Kanto branch road in the Tokyo-Yokohama metropolitan area, which was completely destroyed by the earthquake, in just three days! How did they manage to think and strategize? Indeed, was there enough time to strategize? I don’t think so. They just swung into action!
It’s easy to procrastinate and put off things till tomorrow. Unlike the Japanese, we Indians find it difficult to take stock of a situation and apply corrective measures. So what is it that makes us the way we are? I know that in an attempt to solve this conundrum I’m raising more questions; but here goes…
- We are the world’s largest democracy, but have democratic participation – the right to elect our leaders – robbed us of the ability to act individually and collectively to bring about meaningful changes?
- As a nation we have a hoary tradition of storytelling, which is deeply ingrained in our moral selves. Is this why we have the tendency to boast of past glory while shirking responsibilities when it comes to action in the present?
- Action produces results which, at times, lend themselves to judgments. Is the fear of being judged that holds us back from taking action?
These and many such questions more often than not pique many of us. But are we not resolute enough as a nation to reflect and act in order to bring about change? Change demands action, and action calls for firmness, discipline and resolution.
How can we create an environment which necessitates people to act collectively, not just talk? Let’s for once realize that “necessity of action takes away the fear of the act, and makes bold resolution the favorite of fortune.”
While I sign off, Barack Obama’s Presidential acceptance speech resonates in my mind. …”Our challenges may be new, the instruments with which we meet them may be new, but the values upon which our success depend – honesty and hard work, courage and fair play, tolerance and curiosity, loyalty and commitment – these things are old. These things are true …. It is time we act!”








