Convenience At A Cost
Saturday, April 21st, 2012The Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) allows mutual fund investments to be held in demateri-alised (demat) form. Like shares, investors can now convert their mutual fund units into an electronic format and store in their demat account. Once converted into demat format, investors can sell units either directly like stocks or through a depositary participant (DP).
The major advantage of this step is that it enables a centralisation of all the funds you have invested in. Instead of multiple account statements, you can have a consolidated statement of your holdings. This makes it simple to track investments. Also, a single snapshot of all mutual fund units in a demat account allows you to buy/sell units without difficulty. The growing popularity of exchange-traded funds, or ETFs, is also driving home the importance of demat accounts.
Sebi’s move is a positive one in the sense that it offers an additional path for transacting in mutual funds and provides a single platform to transact across multiple fund houses and their allied schemes. For a majority of existing demat account holders, this platform is fairly opportune and favourable. According to some estimates, roughly 50 per cent of mutual fund investors already own demat accounts.
Large distributors of mutual funds are also encouraging clients to hand over their paper certificates (in the form of account statements) to NSDL, India’s largest depository, and hold them in electronic form. Industry experts say this would help distributors save on postage, stationery and infrastructure costs. However, despite the advantages, many new retail investors have not warmed up to the idea of holding mutual fund units in demat form citing a number of problems.
Additional Costs: Holding mutual fund units in a demat account means investors pay account opening and annual account maintenance fees. Even if you have a demat account, there are transaction costs. This is critical for low-yield debt funds which are further impacted by transaction costs.
No Physical Statement: The investor ceases to receive a physical account statement from the AMC/ registrar and transfer (R&T) agent.
AMC Cord Cut: Once units are dematerialised, the fund holder loses the comfort of dealing directly with the issuer or the R&T agent.
Cumbersome Procedure: With a demat account you obtain a conversion request form (CRF) and submit it along with your account statement to your DP. After due verification, the DP coordinates with the AMC and its R&T agent, which after verification credits the mutual fund units to your demat account.
More Players: Units held in paper form do not carry any risk for the issuing company or for the holder. In the non-demat format, only two persons are involved — the unit holder and the fund house. On the other hand, holding MF units in demat form means you have the demat provider, the clearing house, the bank and the stock exchange in the fray. Then there is the 12.5 per cent service tax. This makes the demat facility a costly affair for a new investor.
It must be remembered that a large number of retail investors in mutual funds do not have demat accounts. Besides, online trading tools lack an advisory interface that retail investors need.
To conclude, while it is smart to use the demat route for investing in mutual funds, ground realities and the cost of taking this route for no tangible additional benefit will continue to act as a barrier to its widespread use.
(This story was published in Businessworld Issue Dated 30-04-2012)







